There are several reasons one may enjoy brewing the old-fashioned way with a stovetop coffee percolator.
Whether you are trying this process out for the first time. Or you have a personal preference for percolated coffee and its brewing process, getting the best stovetop coffee percolator is an essential factor in enjoying well-brewed percolated coffee.
Making a purchasing decision can be tasking if you are really determined to get the best product in the market. And this is why I have put together a selected list of the best coffee percolator you can use on a stovetop.
This list has been put together based on several purchasing factors that have been carefully considered, thorough product research, and client reviews.
So if you would like to pass on doing a cumbersome self-research before making a buying decision, you should take a look at these top stovetop coffee percolators I have put together for you;
Product Comparison table for best stovetop coffee percolator
Last update on 2021-09-16 at 09:21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
Overall Best Stovetop Coffee Percolator – Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite
The Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Percolator is popular among coffee lovers for making great-tasting coffee.
The product comes in a sleek, polished, and durable stainless steel martial that gives your countertop a stylish touch. And you can get it in 8 and 12-cup sizes, which makes it suitable even for family use.
You can also use this percolator on your camping trips if you want.
Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Percolator offers some level of versatility. As the percolator can also double as a kettle for heating up water for other uses.
The product offers the following features to give users the best brewing experience;
- Dishwasher-safe parts for easy cleaning after use
- A glass knob to monitor your percolating process if you wish
- Grip handle that is comfortable for handling and pouring after the brewing process
- Permanent filter basket so you do not need to spend on disposable filters
- Airtight lid that seals in heat so you can enjoy hot coffee
Best Budget stovetop coffee percolator – Primula Today Aluminum Stove Top Percolator Maker
You can enjoy rich-tasting coffee from a stovetop percolator on a smaller budget with the Primula Today Aluminum Stove Top Percolator Maker.
This percolator provides you with 9 cups of coffee in a single brew, which means you don’t have to compromise on size just because you are paying less. But even at this capacity, it is compact enough for camping and other outdoor activities.
The Primula Today Aluminum Stove Top Percolator Maker is made of food-grade aluminum with a plastic handle for a comfortable grip. And it is compatible with most cooking stoves used in any regular home.
Features of this stovetop percolator include;
- A see-through knob so you can monitor your brewing process
- Cool to touch plastic handle to prevent burns during handling and pouring of hot coffee brew.
- Percolator comes useful for heating water for other purposes
- Spacious filter basket for more coffee grounds
Best Stovetop Espresso maker – GROSCHE Milano Stovetop Espresso Maker
The GROSCHE Milano Stovetop Espresso Maker comes in a sophisticated, stylish design that gives it an expensive look. And you can get it in red, black, silver and white, depending on your preference.
This stovetop espresso maker boasts of a high-quality EN301 food-grade aluminum material, and it is offered for sale in different sizes of 3, 6, and 9 espresso cup sizes.
The GROSCHE Milano Stovetop Espresso Maker is suitable for home and office use. It can be used quickly with your gas stove, camp gas, and electric stove but will brew slowly on a glass stove.
Relevant features of the product include;
- A safety valve to measure the quantity of water to use in the brew
- Rubber coated handle that is soft to touch and has a burn guard to prevent accidents during handling and pouring of hot coffee brew
- Silicon gasket prevents your espresso maker from leaks
Best Large stovetop coffee percolator – Coleman Stovetop Coffee Percolator
Coleman offers you a large-capacity, full-stainless steel coffee percolator that you can use for groups, especially during your camping trips and other outdoor activities.
The Coleman 12-cup Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator is lightweight, making it easy to carry along on trips. And the manufacturers boast of non-corrosive, easy-to-wipe, durable stainless steel material you will enjoy using.
The percolator does not come with markings to determine measurements, but users do not seem to see this since the product has proven quite efficient for making rich-tasting hot coffee.
Features of the Coleman 12-cup Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator include;
- See-through glass knob for monitoring your percolation process
- A convenient handle for easy handling and pouring after brewing
- Filter basket with lid for easy brewing
Best Large stovetop coffee percolator for Espresso – Bialetti Express Moka Pot
Bialetti Express Moka Pot comes in various cup sizes, and this 12 demitasse cup capacity is the largest you can get. So if you have a few friends over or need a product for your small family, it will come in handy.
This stovetop percolator is aesthetically beautiful and classic, with an ergonomic handle for safe handling and pouring after brewing.
The product also boasts high-quality aluminum that is safe to use, easy to clean and maintain. Other features of the Bialetti Express Moka Pot are;
- A safety valve to determine water quantity for your brew
- Product material requires cleaning with water only even though it is not dishwasher safe
Best Vintage stovetop coffee percolator – GSI Outdoors 8 Cup Enamelware Percolator Coffee Pot
If you are looking for an old-fashioned stovetop percolator, you will find the GSI Outdoors 8 Cup Enamelware Percolator Coffee Pot is a good fit for your taste.
Although this vintage enamelware is specifically designed for outdoor uses like camping and RV, nothing stops you from using it on a stove in the comfort of your home. And one additional perk to its outdoor design is that you can use it over open fires.
If you think the 8-cup capacity will not work for you because you have many people to cater to, you should consider getting the 12-cup variant to better suit your needs.
The GSI Outdoors 8 Cup Enamelware Percolator Coffee Pot also comes with the following features;
- See-through resin cap that allows you to monitor the percolating process
- Three-ply construction technology, which maximizes heat distribution so that your finished brew comes out well heated.
Recommended accessories for stovetop coffee percolator
If you do not like grounds and sediments in your coffee brew, you may want to get disposable coffee filters to strain your coffee before you drink it.
This is why users buy disposable filters, as most coffee makers tend to come with permanent stainless steel filters for brewing. But these filters often let some grounds flow through into your brew.
Disposable filters capture loose grounds and even trap coffee oils in your coffee. They are affordable and readily available for purchase.
If you prefer to have your coffee properly filtered with disposable filters, you should consider getting these recommended options;
- Melitta #4 Cone Coffee Filters, White, 100 Count (Pack of 6)
- Brew Rite Rockline Wrap Around Percolator Coffee Filters
- Tops Perma-Brew 3 Year Re-useable Coffee Filter, Disk
One common problem with percolators is the tendency of the top knobs to break off after some use, especially when made of glass. And even plastic knobs have been known to melt during the brewing process in some products.
This is obviously because with percolators, your coffee brews under constant heat. Glass knobs tend to expand and contract during the process, making them more vulnerable to break.
Fortunately, you can buy extra knobs alongside your product choice, so you are not left stranded if you experience a crack with your original knob while brewing your coffee.
Knobs are affordable and available in various sizes, and if you are not sure about size options, you may choose knobs with a universal fit for your product.
- Tops Mfg Fitz-All Replacement Percolator Top, Glass, 13/16-Inch to 1-1/2-Inch
- Univen Plastic Knob Top and Washer Ring Compatible with Farberware Yosemite Coffee Percolators
Of course, you want to have your cleaning accessories at hand, for when the time comes for you to give your coffee percolator a thorough cleaning. And you may choose to get some baking soda or vinegar, depending on product compatibility and personal preference.
You may also get a soft-bristled brush to get rid of coffee grounds in corners, especially in your filter basket. And you should have your soft sponge or dishcloth and mild soap dish for cleaning appliances in your kitchen.
Buying Guide for choosing the best stovetop coffee percolator
Once you have decided that you prefer a stovetop coffee percolator over its electric counterpart. The next hurdle would be to ensure you get the best stovetop coffee percolator available in the market.
This can be a tough decision to make. But if you let your personal needs and relevant factors guide your decision, then you will most likely end up with a product you will be thoroughly satisfied with.
There are no perfect products, but the aim here is to find a coffee maker that will be worth the price and experience and will leave you looking forward to your next cup of coffee.
In selecting the choices above, the following factors were considered and will inevitably be a helpful guide for you too:
Budget is a necessary factor to consider when making any purchase. Because it is what determines the options that are available for you to pick from.
If you are testing out a coffee percolator for the first time, it makes sense to go for a more affordable product. And if you want a stovetop espresso maker, you will also have to adjust your budget to fit accordingly.
Fortunately, percolators are sold at affordable prices. And you can get a good percolator, like the Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite, for a price below $30.
Whatever your budget is, the trick is to find the best available percolator you can get within your budget range so you can enjoy every dime spent.
Cleaning and maintenance
The ability to clean your product with ease will not only encourage you to make the best use of it. But it also helps your percolator last as long as possible before you have to replace it.
Not all percolators are dishwasher safe because of the material they have been made with. But even if you have to hand-wash your product choice, keeping it clean should not be a cumbersome process for you.
Ease of use
Percolators are easy to brew with. But when it comes to ease of use, you also have to consider the ease of handling the percolator when it has become hot. And the chances of getting consistent results without just sticking to the simple brewing process.
It is sufficient to get a percolator that performs its brewing functions consistently well. But some percolators can double as a kettle for boiling water, and it will come in handy, especially when you are going camping and need to pack light.
It would also be better to get a percolator that brews rich, concentrated coffee if you drink specialty coffee every now and then. This way, you can control the concentration of your coffee to your desired taste, rather than have to visit the café whenever you want an espresso or cappuccino.
Your choice of capacity will depend on how much of a coffee drinker you are. And whether you plan to caffeinate your friends and family too.
You can get a coffee percolator from 1 cup up to 12 cup sizes, but note that coffee cup sizes are smaller than the regular cups or mugs people often use in their homes.
So whether you are buying a percolator for regular coffee or espresso, take note of the cup sizes in which they have been measured.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Moka pot different from a percolator?
A Moka pot functions differently from a percolator, even though coffee is brewed on the stove in both cases.
The Moka pot is often referred to as a stovetop espresso maker because it creates a similar brew to that, commonly used in making espresso and other coffee variants.
The stovetop percolator, on the other hand, uses a repetitive steaming process to create regular coffee. And if you check the makeup of both appliances, you will find that the basket for coffee grounds in the Moka pot is often located in the middle chamber, while that of the percolator is at the top.
Both appliances brew potent coffee. But if you prefer specialty coffee variants, the Moka pot is a perfect recommendation.
What is the best way to clean my coffee percolator?
In cleaning your coffee percolator, you should ensure you stick to the guidelines in your user manual to avoid compromising the functionality and durability of your product.
Avoid using a dishwasher unless it is expressly recommended by your product manufacturer because washing a non-compatible product in a dishwasher can ruin its quality.
Some coffee percolators only require that you rinse them thoroughly, even without soap after every use. But once in a while, you should clean your product thoroughly, so you can maintain its freshness.
This can be done effectively using baking soda or vinegar in the following steps;
- If you have just finished using your percolator, you should allow it to cool down for easy handling for a proper wash.
- To clean the percolator, fill your pot with 2-3 spoons of baking soda and water. You can mix this with white vinegar if you are trying to get rid of stubborn stains.
- If you are using only vinegar, mix the vinegar with water and pour it into the percolator.
- Light up your percolator and let it perk
- Empty the percolator and refill with another vinegar solution, turn it back on to perk.
- Let the solution sit in for a while after perking while your percolator cools before emptying it again.
- Rinse thoroughly by boiling clear water; ensure you get rid of all traces, taste, and smell of any solution you have used.
- Remove coffee stains from the pot exterior by wiping or scrubbing with a non-abrasive dishcloth.
- Wash filter basket and other removable parts according to manufacturer’s instructions
- Allow your product parts to dry thoroughly before reassembling for your subsequent brewing process.
How long does it take a percolator to brew?
The length of time you will spend percolating your coffee will ultimately depend on how strong you want your brew. But generally, percolating coffee beyond 10 minutes will most likely burn your coffee.
The optimal time for a perfect brew is between 5-8 minutes. But the most important thing is that you should keep an eye on your brewing process to ensure it is well brewed. So that you can get your desired results.
What is the best type of coffee to use in a percolator?
When it comes to finding a suitable coffee roast, your choice of coffee will depend on your personal preference. But dark roast coffee usually tends to come out bitter, while you are likely to miss out on the subtleties of your brew when you use light roast coffee.
The recommended roast type of coffee for percolation is the medium roast.
In terms of coffee grinds, fine-ground coffee is more likely to flow through the coffee filter and get into your brew. Hence it is advised that you make use of coarse grinds when brewing through percolation.
It is also best to make use of freshly ground coffee. You can grind your beans yourself if you have a coffee grinder. But if you do not, you should look out for freshness in any coffee grounds you are purchasing.
Freshly ground coffee will give you more flavor and a richer taste than you will get from coffee that has been grounded over some time.
Stovetop coffee percolators have continued to stand the test of time. Even with the introduction of automatic-drip coffee makers and electric percolators were into.
These products are relatively cheap, efficient and make coffee brewing an enjoyable process for those who love the experience.
However, there are cheaper options, like the Primula Today Aluminum Stove Top Percolator Maker and others you can choose from, according to your needs and preferences.